![]() |
|
On the subject of ship battles - Printable Version +- Team Spartan Cookies & Milk Forums (https://teamscm.co.uk) +-- Forum: Garry's Mod (https://teamscm.co.uk/forum-4.html) +--- Forum: General (https://teamscm.co.uk/forum-39.html) +--- Thread: On the subject of ship battles (/thread-3529.html) Pages:
1
2
|
On the subject of ship battles - The17thDoctor - 09-12-2020 I'm pretty sure every members on TSCM have already battled before and knows what a battle is like today :
These kinds of battle can be redundant and may I say, boring. If y'all can't accept that to some degree, using ingenuity and our own tricks to battle is a way to get the advantage then what's the point of fighting ? A battle should be dynamic, people should struggle to keep their ships in a right shape and it shouldn't be a weapon outfit problematic only. There's many starfalls in the past I would've loved to use in true battles that I couldn't as otherwise I would've been considered a cheater. ( Blocking torpedoes ; Switching weapon types mid-fight ; using a starfall mechanic to insert weapons in a jammed area etc.. ) Why don't we do true battles ? Battles where everything's allowed to some degree ( e.g jumping from a galaxy to another constantly to avoid your opponent as this would just make the fight last forever and whatnots ). Now I know there can be some problems related to doing this like:
To which I'd answer : Isn't it the point of competition ? The ultimate satisfaction is to see someone's streak go down cause you found the thing he did not think about. Of course, I realise that not being able to code can technically count as a disadvantage but there's no rule telling you to not try and sympathise with starfall / E2 coders to take the advantage together. Maybe you both share tricks that each other don't know about, I know for myself I'd totally be open to people requesting help with fight. Tell me what you guys think about that proposition, let's make battles intense, stressful and fun ! RE: On the subject of ship battles - Caprica - 09-12-2020 I also agree that battles are a little lackluster, and this also feeds into the faction system from the other post. I agree in increasing the dynamics of the situation and I think a good remedy could be the inclusion of world events/factors. E.g. things in the world effect different stats, this would make placement of your ship much more important. For example, it could be that any ship close to the lava planet would experience constant damage to the shields as some sort of "radiation" induced damage. Another example would be that the entire Pegasus galaxy has some sort of field that reduces overall shield effectiveness, this would make it so a ship can jump to Pegasus if it was to "lure" someone to a place with worse shields. There could also be moving events, such as an ion cloud that prevents cloaked ships, or even prevent ships using FTL. I also like the idea of using code as a bargaining chip in battles. I think the key thing is here having the ability to give someone an SF script that they can use but not read. For example I have a chip that lets me target multiple people and depending on if the weapon can "see" that person (I used a ray trace), it determines which target to fire on. Now lets say as an agreement to ending my war with Anubis I give him this chip, what is to stop him from just copying and starting the war again? If I give him access to the chip but also add code that instantly self destructs his ship if he declares war on me, he cant edit it to remove that line of code. What do you think? RE: On the subject of ship battles - mariofludd - 09-12-2020 Another problem, is that if one person has a warp drive that can go anywhere, they can warp behind you, and if you're trying to run a good loadout, all your weapons will only be able to shoot forward, and maybe to the sides. Fighting shuttles is another problem because it then turns into shuttle v shuttle, or your ship blowing up because they've shoved themselves into some corner of your ship, warped into your ship when your shield is down, or just went into one of your many blindspots because pulsar emitters do trash damage against shuttles and are useless against ships because they have like no range. RE: On the subject of ship battles - Caprica - 09-12-2020 I think that's a good thing though, it forces you to add weapons all around. Shuttles dont have as much hull as the other ships, but they can actually move. I think its a cool design conisderation! Although I wish the prop limit for gyro was increased RE: On the subject of ship battles - The17thDoctor - 09-12-2020 Starfalls can already prevent code from being read by anyone using the shared area. RE: On the subject of ship battles - Caprica - 09-12-2020 Shared area? Like if I give you a chip you cant open it to read it? RE: On the subject of ship battles - mariofludd - 09-12-2020 (09-12-2020, 08:04 PM)Caprica Wrote: Shared area? Like if I give you a chip you cant open it to read it? They'd have to right click > load to tool > alt click to use it, but yes. RE: On the subject of ship battles - Person8880 - 11-12-2020 The problem with what you're proposing is that it's not really an interesting or fair mechanic to have something like a chip that spawns props in front of projectiles to block them. It doesn't really add anything, and in fact I'd argue takes away some of the fun, especially if everyone had them as then 2/3 weapon types are useless. Imagine seeing a sci-fi show where ships are fighting and then projectiles just fizzle out between them because a barrel appeared on them, it might be funny for a minute or two, but after that it's just anti-climatic and immersion breaking. I realise that the battle mechanics could have many improvements, but it's hard to come up with things that would truly make them more engaging while fitting in the limits of the engine and gamemode. I'm open to suggestions of possible enhancements to mechanics that would add more depth. A few ideas I've had are:
RE: On the subject of ship battles - The17thDoctor - 11-12-2020 I do get the point of starfall just breaking any kind of immersion, but even some of the more standard tactics in battle that are using TSCM's entities without breaking any sort of unwritten rule is sometimes considered "cheating" ( like using a ship's manoeuvrability to actually put yourself in someone's dead angles or repeatedly jumping ). Maybe I was going abit too extreme with starfalls but I do still think that the current battle "rules" can be somewhat boring and just layout based. Problem is that strategy is kind of hard to implement in a way that facing the opponent would lead to richer fights. On another note, I do like the idea of making projectiles destructible by weapons, we could easily imagine a new kind of turret that would act as Multi-Cannons ( gatlings ) which would make for some greater use of physical projectiles based combats. ( These turrets would maybe have a better turn rate in order to compensate for the fast speed of projectiles but terrible damage on shield / hull ) RE: On the subject of ship battles - Caprica - 11-12-2020 I like the idea of destructible projectiles. I also maybe like the idea of being able to destroy/props entities. E.g. I fire enough on your weapons I can destroy them, or if I fire at your bridge you have no bridge. Its not like there's much risk since everything is duped anyways |