Letting people comment approval on applications turns them into popularity contests and has been covered before (and is precisely what's happening here).
Yes, the member application process could be improved, but to do so would require numerous trustworthy people to have the time/inclination to review applications, which isn't an easy to thing to make happen. The alternative is to relax the requirements, but that runs the risk of abusive players making it through and requires just as much reviewing, just after approval instead of before where damage has already been done.
The original question of this thread has been answered now so I'm closing it. In the future, bring up this kind of thing in the application's thread and not here. If people have suggestions on how to improve the member application process that isn't "count number of approval/disapproval comments from other members", feel free to make a new thread.