I think that by that point we can all agree on the fact that finding solutions to make the Membership Application a better system seems like the quest for the Holy Grail.
However I won't stop grinding my head until this system gets at least a tad better.
A quick sum up of what the problem is :
Person does not have enough time to judge everyone applying as TSCM is a hobby and not a job.
He cannot distribute the work effort to admins or mods as most of them have jobs aswell.
He cannot distribute the task to other members as that was the case before and did not end well.
Today, previously bad behaving members gets themselves stuck to regular because of the first problem stated above.
All of this results in a myriade of applications and potential members being forgotten
Multiple solutions were proposed but were not meeting this criterias or were creating new problems sadly.
Now what do I have to offer you might ask.
I propose to you person to "hire" some trustful members as judges to look out on people asking to be ranked up.
These members would be kept secret as they'd need not to cause bias from regulars trying to behave when they're around.
Note that the hired member would be volunteer to do that job. They would not gain any reward from that nor would they get any perks in exchange.
The eventual issues I see about this idea :
Since these members would be kept secret, there would be risks of leaks about who's part of this.
These judges are not flawless, they would sure be most of the time unbiased but could enlighten the picture for their friends.
And maybe some other issues I did not spot.
If you guys have any idea on how to improve my proposition, feel free to reply to this thread.
The17thDoctor: Server take me to the most handsome person srcds_linux: I cant send people to themselves...
-Recruit new moderators, who can dedicate more time to TSCM than those who have a job.
-> Advantages:
Would allow to have a better visibility of the behaviors of the players, and their changes.
-> Disadvantages:
Well, I haven't found one yet ...
-As you had already slipped in our conversations, the possibility of involving the Super Members for the candidacies.
Advantages:
More or less the same as the first idea.
Disadvantages:
All super members are not necessarily active people, or the best to judge the behavior of others (I am not targeting anyone, do not make me say what I did not say c: )
So I haven't been on TSCM that much(as well as lurk on the forum as well).
So on to my Idea. I agree we should have a group of people (Members,Super Members,ect). But Change them around every like idk 4 to 5 months(Or what ever time frame would seem reasonable). This would get rid of or lower the chance of them getting leaked to Regulars and making them Biased.
Of course this can have some downsides as well so change it how you would like
(27-05-2020, 02:00 PM)LTN_Akagi Wrote: So I haven't been on TSCM that much(as well as lurk on the forum as well).
So on to my Idea. I agree we should have a group of people (Members,Super Members,ect). But Change them around every like idk 4 to 5 months(Or what ever time frame would seem reasonable). This would get rid of or lower the chance of them getting leaked to Regulars and making them Biased.
Of course this can have some downsides as well so change it how you would like
The problem with your idea is that there isn't alot of active members on the server, so that will turn in a closed circle I think