Team Spartan Cookies & Milk Forums
  • Issue Tracker
  • Donations
  • Search
  • Member List
  • Help

Register

Team Spartan Cookies & Milk Forums Garry's Mod Projects v
1 2 3 4 5 9 Next »
Corridor Pack for SBEP
Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Pages (6): « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next »
Threaded Mode
Corridor Pack for SBEP
17-07-2018, 03:13 PM,
#11
Thunaer Offline
...Reuniting the Fleet...
****
Posts: 175
Threads: 19
Joined: Feb 2014
RE: Corridor Pack for SBEP
Well,
as someone who's been working with source for quite a few years I thought I could give both of you some feedback.

Surely it's a good thing to come up with new SBEP models which will eventually give all of us more options when building ships.
It's also great to see that this is coming from the TSCM community itself. However I have two major concerns with these new models.

First of all no offense, but the texturing is awful. By using Veegis already existing materials you probably avoided a lot of work.
However that's not what you should do in this case. His materials work great on his very own models due to their small size and purpose.
Your corridors on the other hand can or will provide enclosed environments for players. So if they mainly consist of the same three colors, with no texture to them whatsoever, they will become fairly boring pretty quickly.
Because of the materials simplicity, combined with the models size I also don't think they match the already existing props or Gmod's aesthetics whatsoever.

Getting some proper texturing done isn't a big deal, however what might cause some actual issues is the following.
As far as I know neither of you are really experienced with modeling for source.
On a server like TSCM, people still build gigantic ships with dozens or maybe even hundreds of corridor pieces. So performance should be the most important aspect when making these new corridors.
If you take a look at the original Modbridge ones you will notice that all of them are incredibly simple. All the detailing comes from the materials and not the models themself. Just like you are supposed to do in Source.
Now with your corridors I fear major performance issues due to all the weird shapes and indents. I'm pretty sure they have at least twice or maybe even thrice the amount of faces and polys of the original modbridge ones.
And that is something which shouldn't be the case on TSCM.
Find
Reply
17-07-2018, 03:24 PM,
#12
Skeleton Offline
Cheating Donating Member ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
****
Posts: 199
Threads: 30
Joined: Nov 2014
RE: Corridor Pack for SBEP
Hello,

I have to say aswell that I'm glad that you two took the initiative to provide new corridors models for the community and I thank you for it.

However as said above, your inexperience in modelling would cause significant performance impact on the server. As you can see, the texture is also important: adding more faces will not make your model look better.

There are some game-industry techniques that you obviously aren't aware of to make great looking models without sacrifying performances.

And about the texturing itself, try to make your own because right now it looks cartoon-ish and not realistic at all. Maybe it appeared to you as a good idea to use the existing ones but they don't fit corridors.

[Image: giphy.gif]
Find
Reply
17-07-2018, 03:59 PM, (This post was last modified: 17-07-2018, 04:10 PM by 4N0NYM. Edited 1 time in total.)
#13
4N0NYM Offline
absens
****
Posts: 561
Threads: 211
Joined: Dec 2014
RE: Corridor Pack for SBEP
First of all thanks for the feedback, i did already some testing with the corridors, because i was aware of the problem with the source engine. I spawned 760 of the corridors without a high lost of performance, even a Prop Resizer worked without any problems.

About the material, yes it was a easier solution for it, but also the models support Submaterial, means you can easily change them with the existing materials, else you might have any suggestions for materials we could take ?
Find
Reply
17-07-2018, 04:06 PM,
#14
Veegi Offline
Marker Translator
Posts: 90
Threads: 6
Joined: Sep 2013
RE: Corridor Pack for SBEP
The corridor models will need proper UV-maps to support any materials other than mine (and the flat light materials), otherwise they might act unpredictably.
This can be seen in some of my models when they are set to another material, as they don't have any UV-maps; my models might get away with it due to them being smaller, but full corridors won't.

ohai
Find
Reply
17-07-2018, 04:11 PM,
#15
Avorius Offline
Valued donator and member
****
Posts: 128
Threads: 47
Joined: Dec 2015
RE: Corridor Pack for SBEP
Hey,

Like the other guys here I'm really glad you guys are putting in the time and the effort to make these models, but there a few things I have to point out;

1. You say you tested the models on your computer with minimal performance loss, what's to say about other peoples computers? Did you test them on a server with the same amount of average props that would be on TSCM?

2. On pretty much all of the corridors, the floor material doesn't line up with their corresponding corridor, making it look the twisted corridor from Ocarina of time.

3. Additionally, on all the corridors the flooring material is too stretched to make it look like a normal floor (It looks like you could fit your foot in between the gaps)

4. High poly nature of the corridor props might cause some serious lag if used excessively, like on most ships on TSCM nowadays.

5. The re-use of Veegi's material (Which was intended for use of the stargazer system), doesn't go well with the grate texture of the floor, they are all solid colours which give you no sense of being in a starship, more like a padded cell.

Good luck on the models.

~Avorius


Find
Reply
17-07-2018, 04:28 PM,
#16
4N0NYM Offline
absens
****
Posts: 561
Threads: 211
Joined: Dec 2014
RE: Corridor Pack for SBEP
Veegi : The models got proper UV maps to support other materials, we tested it from the begining.

Avorous : 1. Yes i tested it with 760 props, wich are (sadly) common prop counts on TSCM.
2. The Floor material look like its twisted, because that are the Models wich are connecting 3 or 4 corridors, if you take a look
on Modbridge you notice its not very diffrent there.
3. The floor material look maybe stretched, but ingame it looks very normal.
4. As i meantion before on another reply, there isnt much to worry about, i tested already everything wich came me into the
mind, and i didnt crashed or got any problems.
5. For that check the reply above.
Find
Reply
17-07-2018, 04:50 PM, (This post was last modified: 17-07-2018, 04:54 PM by The17thDoctor. Edited 1 time in total.)
#17
The17thDoctor Offline
TSCM Average Enjoyer
****
Posts: 1,100
Threads: 249
Joined: Oct 2015
RE: Corridor Pack for SBEP
Like ano, I would like to say thanks to the replies and would argue on ano's point being he tested it with 760 corridor props. Even tho people with less great computers could suffer more lag, if ano has the same FPS with 760 normal modbridges and 760 custom modbridges, it means the amount of lag is the same and so that the prop is ok performance-wise.

How ano also said, we try to do what we can to get proper UV Mapping in case of someone changing the materials and in fact, we chose Veegi's just as a support texture for people who would like to change for another one. So it might not look that great but its meant to be modified like "every" people who uses those types of corridors do with them. Even tho we could change materials for a less cartoon-ish effect as Skeleton mentioned for a more realistic look.

Lots of combos are possible and I tried using these ones cause I think they were looking good for the corridor and that they keep the color there we originaly chose. Tell me what you think.

Edit : I think the little "ident" there are on the vertical light strips could be removed too, its a detail so pointless I dont really see why its there


Attached Files Thumbnail(s)
   

The17thDoctor: Server take me to the most handsome person
srcds_linux: I cant send people to themselves...
Website Find
Reply
17-07-2018, 04:56 PM, (This post was last modified: 18-07-2018, 11:03 AM by Thunaer. Edited 2 times in total.)
#18
Thunaer Offline
...Reuniting the Fleet...
****
Posts: 175
Threads: 19
Joined: Feb 2014
RE: Corridor Pack for SBEP
(17-07-2018, 03:59 PM)4N0NYM Wrote: [...] About the material, yes it was a easier solution for it, but also the models support Submaterial, means you can easily change them with the existing materials, else you might have any suggestions for materials we could take ?

The submaterial tool is a weak excuse. Of course people can use it to adjust the materials to their liking. However with that attitude you could also just use the source developer materials ("dev/dev_measuregeneric01" etc.) because it doesn't matter afterall, heh?
You can't expect every player to put some extra effort into these props before using them just because their creator was too lazy to put some extra time into proper texturing.
There is a big difference between changing the materials ingame so a corridor piece fits your own ship slightly better and trying to make a prop visually appealing in the first place.
As Skeleton already said, just make your own materials. Put some effort into it and maybe add smaller details instead of re-using already existing materials which we have all seen thousands of times already.
Find
Reply
17-07-2018, 05:01 PM,
#19
The17thDoctor Offline
TSCM Average Enjoyer
****
Posts: 1,100
Threads: 249
Joined: Oct 2015
RE: Corridor Pack for SBEP
(17-07-2018, 04:56 PM)Brent Wrote: The submaterial tool is a weak excuse. Of course people can use it to adjust the materials to their liking. However with that attitude you could also just use the source developer materials ("dev/dev_measuregeneric01" etc.) because it doesn't matter afterall, heh?
You can't expect every player to put some extra effort into these props before using them just because their creator was too lazy to put some extra time into proper texturing.
There is a big difference between changing the materials ingame so a corridor piece fits your own ship slightly better and trying to make a prop visually appealing in the first place.
As Skeleton already said, just make your own materials. Put some effort into and maybe add smaller details instead of re-using already existing materials which we have all seen thousands of times already.

Well we'll try something but I / Ano cant promise anything, being total newbies in this domain. Replying later if there's any progress in making our own materials.

The17thDoctor: Server take me to the most handsome person
srcds_linux: I cant send people to themselves...
Website Find
Reply
17-07-2018, 05:33 PM,
#20
Skeleton Offline
Cheating Donating Member ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
****
Posts: 199
Threads: 30
Joined: Nov 2014
RE: Corridor Pack for SBEP
Hello again,

I don't think spawning alot of corridors in Sandbox will tell you if your model is good performance-wise or not.

What I would like to know is the amount of vertices, edges and faces your models has. That only will tell us if the model is good for this engine or not.

Other than than that I would like to thank you again for your efforts. I don't want to sound killjoy or anything but I think that's something we needed to point you out.

It's still a good way to learn modelling than training by making these models even if we may not use them. Maybe it will help you making better versions of them in the future, that's what I wish to both of you at least.

[Image: giphy.gif]
Find
Reply
« Next Oldest | Next Newest »
Pages (6): « Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 Next »


  • View a Printable Version
Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread:
Contact UsTeam Spartan Cookies & MilkReturn to TopLite (Archive) ModeMark all forums readRSS Syndication

Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.